Tractor

Tractor
Showing posts with label leave to appeal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label leave to appeal. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 22, 2015

COTTFN files for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in Enbridge Line 9B case

In October, I posted about the Federal Court of Appeal decision to deny an appeal by the Chippewas of the Thames First Nation ("COTTFN") from the decision of the National Energy Board ("NEB") approving the Enbridge Line 9B Reversal and Line 9 Capacity Expansion Project application.  COTTFN has now filed an application for leave to appeal the Federal Court of Appeal's decision to the Supreme Court of Canada.  Given that there was a dissenting opinion from one of the FCA judges and that the subject matter of the appeal concerns the role of administrative tribunals in relation to the Crown's duty to consult with and accommodate First Nations, there would seem to be a good chance that leave will be granted.

Thursday, April 30, 2015

4640 John Deere case goes up to the Court of Appeal

I previously wrote about a small claims case in Saskatchewan where a man had bid $18,000 at auction to purchase a 4640 John Deere (with loader) but had mistakenly been allowed to pay only $1,800.  The cashier had entered the bid amount incorrectly, missing the last zero in the price.  The purchaser refused to pay any additional amount and claimed that $1,800 was the bid amount.  The Court did not allow the purchaser to take advantage of the mistake and ordered payment of the balance of the $18,000 on the basis of unjust enrichment.

Well, the decision was appealed by the purchaser (who referred to the trial as a "mockery of the judicial system) and has made its way up to the Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan.  I invite you to read the Court of Appeal's reasons for dismissing the purchaser's application for leave to appeal (leave to appeal a decision by the Court of Queen's Bench that dismissed an initial appeal), which set out the various interesting grounds of appeal, but here is the conclusion:
[The Purchaser] fails to come to grips with a very simple issue—he was found on the evidence to owe money to pay for farm equipment he purchased at an auction. He had the opportunity at trial to explain why he should not have to pay and passed on the opportunity. His arguments have nothing to do with the fundamental issue, i.e. he did not pay his bid price for equipment because of the mistake of fact and he owes the money. One can only surmise that his actions and his whole argument are simply an attempt to avoid payment.
He has raised no question of law and the appeal has no merit in any event.
The application for leave is dismissed with costs in the usual manner.

Tuesday, July 8, 2014

Manitoba Court determines that proposed pipeline is provincial, not federal

In a post last December, I reported about a case in Manitoba being fought over the jurisdiction of a proposed pipeline - federal or provincial.  A group of affected landowners had sought leave to appeal a decision of the Surface Rights Board and had also requested the judicial review of Manitoba's decision to approve the pipeline.  The leave to appeal matter was put on hold pending the outcome of the judicial review.  In January of this year, the Court of Queen's Bench issued its decision on the judicial review.

The landowners applied to the Court for an order declaring that the pipeline is interprovincial and, therefore, outside the jurisdiction of the Province of Manitoba.  They had previously applied to the National Energy Board (NEB) for the same order, but that application was rejected.

On the basis of the test set out in the Supreme Court of Canada decision in Westcoast Energy Inc. v. Canada (National Energy Board), the Court ruled that the Manitoba pipeline was provincial in nature and, therefore, within the jurisdiction of the Province.  The Court found that the EOG pipeline (the one at issue in the case) and the MIPL pipeline (the cross-border pipeline to which the EOG pipeline would connect) were not a single federal undertaking, and that the EOG pipeline is not integral to the operation of the MIPL pipeline.  On that basis, the EOG pipeline did not become part of the interprovincial MIPL pipeline for the purpose of determining its jurisdiction.  As the EOG pipeline is located within the boundaries of Manitoba, it is a provincial pipeline.

Read the decision at: Daniels et al v. EOG Resources et al.

Thursday, June 12, 2014

First Nation granted leave to appeal NEB's Enbridge Line 9B Reversal approval

The Chippewas of the Thames First Nation (COTTFN) has been granted leave to appeal the NEB's approval of the Enbridge Line 9B Reversal and Line 9 Capacity Expansion Project.  The COTTFN had to apply to the Federal Court of Appeal for leave as the first step in its challenge to the NEB decision on the basis that the Federal Crown failed to consult with it over the project.  COTTFN disputes that its participation in the NEB process or public consultation by Enbridge constitutes proper consultation by the Crown.  Read COTTFN's press release on the leave to appeal decision at: FEDERAL COURT OF APPEAL GRANTS CHIPPEWAS LEAVE.

The outcome of the appeal is obviously up in the air, but it is promising to see that COTTFN's arguments about Crown consultation will be heard by the Courts.  Similar arguments were raised by First Nations in the initial Line 9A reversal application hearing, but no appeals were taken from the NEB's approval of that project.  Without an appeal to the Courts, the NEB is left to make the only decisions about whether its own "consultation" process with First Nations fulfills the Crown's obligations.  A conflict of interest? 

Depending on the outcome of the appeal before the Federal Court of Appeal, this may be the kind of case that will go to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Tuesday, June 10, 2014

Gas supply easement binds any severed parcels

The Alberta Court of Appeal rejected an application for leave to appeal from a decision that found that a gas supply easement continued to apply after a lot was severed into three parts (creating two new lots).  The owners of the original parcel applied to the Alberta Utilities Commission for an order directing the Evergreen Gas Co-op to discharge its easement from the newly subdivided lots.  The Commission refused, and the owners sought leave to appeal the decision to the Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal confirmed that the easement, which was a general easement that applied to the entire original property (rather than a limited easement or ROW over a particular portion of the property), would continue to apply to any subdivided parts of the property.  The Court rejected the argument by the owners that the imposition of the easement on the new parcels was nevertheless "improper" within the meaning of the Gas Distribution Act.  The Court also rejected the argument that the easement "agreement" (the easement was created when the owners agreed to receive gas service from the Co-op, the terms of the contract being statutorily set) was "unconscionable" - how could the contract be unconscionable when the owners had applied for gas service and the terms of the contract were imposed by statute?

Read the decision at: Andre v Evergreen Gas Co-op Ltd.

Friday, October 7, 2011

Alberta farm land tax assessment case sent back for re-hearing

Madam Justice J.M. Ross of the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench in Edmonton has allowed an appeal of a property tax assessment decision involving farm land.  She granted leave to appeal to the Applicant, Associated Developers (AD), from a 2010 decision of the Composite Assessment Review Board (CARB) assessing AD's land as industrial property rather than as farm land.  Justice Ross then heard the appeal, overturned the decision of the CARB and sent the case back to the Board for re-determination.

The Property in question, located in Edmonton, was assessed as industrial property at a value of $6,723,500 in the 2010 assessment year for the 2009 taxation year.  The relevant valuation period for the 2010 assessment was therefore 2009.  Had the Property been assessed as farm land, the assessed value would have been $863,000.   The Applicant complained to the CARB, asserting that the property should have been assessed as farm land.  The Applicant had filed with the CARB annual leases between AD and a farmer for the years 1999-2010.  The leases included terms that the lands would be used solely for agricultural purposes. 

The City of Edmonton (arguing for the industrial land assessment) argued that the crop of hay on the property had not been harvested in 2009.  The City's position was that if the crop was not cut, it could not be said to have been produced and, therefore, was not used for farming operations and could not be classified as farm land.  AD argued in response that the land could still be farm land even if not hayed in 2009, as there are many circumstances in which people leave land idle for a year for a variety of sound agricultural reasons.

Justice Ross allowed the appeal because the CARB failed to provide adequate reasons for its decision and failed to identify the appropriate legal tests in its reasons.  These were breaches of the principles of natural justice and the duty to be fair.  She cancelled the decision and sent the matter back to the CARB to be re-heard.

Read the decision at: Associated Developers Ltd. v. Edmonton (City).

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Ontario Farms Taxed at Industrial Rates?

Last week, I reported on a Court decision denying a farm operation leave to appeal a property tax assessment decision.  Read the Better Farming story on the case at the following link: Ontario Farms Taxed at Industrial Rates?

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Farm loses bid for appeal of MPAC tax assessment decision

Lorentz Farms Limited owns a 2.66 acre parcel of land located in Wellesley Township.  As part of the applicant’s adjacent farm operations, machinery and equipment used to dry alfalfa and turn it into pellets is located on this property.  The Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (“MPAC”) classifies land use for tax purposes.  MPAC classified the subject property as industrial and commercial.  Believing the proper classification to be agricultural, and thus subject to a lower rate of tax, the applicant appealed this classification before the Assessment Review Board ("ARB") in 2009.  During the ARB hearings, valuation of the property was conceded and it was agreed that the only issue between the parties was classification of the property.  The ARB determined that the treatment of the Alfalfa on the property amounted to “processing” within the meaning of s.6(1)(1)(i) of the Act and therefore, the MPAC’s classification was deemed to be correct.

Lorentz Farms then applied for leave to appeal the decision of the ARB to the Ontario Divisional Court.  Justice McGarry of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dismissed the application for leave to appeal, ruling:
In my view, it is clear based upon the agreed facts, that “processing” took place as the treatment of alfalfa by grinding into a powder and producing pellets amounts to “processing”. Therefore, as it is likely that the operations on the subject property amount to “processing” within the meaning of s.6(1)(1)(i), the property was properly was classified as industrial and accordingly, there is no reason to doubt the decision of the ARB.
Read the decision at: Lorentz Farms Limited et al v. MPAC.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Enbridge denied leave to appeal in Bloor Street Explosion case

Enbridge Gas Distribution Inc. is going back to trial on Occupational Health and Safety Act charges related to the Bloor Street natural gas explosion in 2003 that killed seven people.  The Ontario Court of Appeal has denied Enbridge's application for leave to appeal an earlier decision by the Superior Court which ordered a new trial in the case.  Justice Watt summarizes the facts:
The Preliminaries
[17] Warren asked Enbridge to identify and mark its underground natural gas pipelines in the area involved in the reconstruction before Warren began excavation. Enbridge contracted with PUL to provide the necessary information for Warren. PUL assigned one of its employees to locate and mark Enbridge’s pipelines in the area affected by the reconstruction.

[18] The PUL employee assigned the task of locating and marking Enbridge’s pipelines in the area affected by the reconstruction neither identified nor marked a three-quarter inch pipeline into the commercial plaza at 3885-3891 Bloor Street West.
The Accident

[19] Warren’s backhoe operator inadvertently struck Enbridge’s unmarked pipeline into the plaza. The displacement dislodged the pipe from its fitting attached to the outside wall of the plaza. An unregulated flow of natural gas escaped into the basement of the plaza.

[20] About six to nine minutes after the pipe had become dislodged, an unknown source of ignition caused the gas to explode. The blast levelled the plaza. The force of the explosion and the ensuing fire damaged or destroyed several structures nearby. Seven people were killed, several more injured.
Read the full decision at: Ontario (Labour) v. Enbridge Gas Distribution Inc.

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Supreme Court of Canada has granted leave to appeal in Berendsen farm contamination case


In the mid-1960s, the Ontario Ministry of Transportation buried asphalt and concrete waste from a highway reconstruction project in an unlined pit on a nearby dairy farm with the owner’s consent. The Berendsens, experienced dairy farmers, purchased the farm in 1981. Shortly thereafter, their cows began to suffer serious health problems, to have a high cull rate, and to produce an unusually low quantity of milk. The immediate cause of the problems was the cows’ unwillingness to drink enough water, but the Berendsens claimed that the waste was the root cause. They alleged that chemicals in the waste had migrated to their well, contaminating the water and making it unpalatable for the cows. Testing showed that the chemicals in the water from the well did not exceed the Ontario Drinking Water Objectives, which set the levels allowed for human consumption. A new well 400 feet from the burial site was also rejected by the herd. When the Berendsens complained to the Ontario government, it arranged for an alternate water source. The herd’s water intake, milk production increased, and overall health improved. Meanwhile, the Ministry of the Environment did some water quality testing of the water in the wells, the barn troughs and the ditch, from which it concluded that the water met the Ontario Drinking Water Objectives and that it was not responsible for the problems. It stopped providing alternate water. The Berendsens sued Ontario in negligence for depositing the waste and then failing to remove the contamination. The trial judge allowed the action and awarded damages of $1,732,400 plus pre‑judgment interest and costs. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the trial judgment and dismissed the action.

The Supreme Court of Canada has granted leave to the Berendsens to appeal the decision of the Ontario Court of Appeal, with costs of the leave application in the cause (i.e. the issue of the costs of the leave to appeal application will be left until the appeal is actually decided by the court).  The hearing date for the appeal has not been set.

Friday, April 16, 2010

Communications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada appeals Keystone XL approval

CEP Press Release - 04/12/2010

TORONTO -- The National Energy Board has approved a pipeline construction project – Keystone XL – that will result in tens of thousands of current and potential Canadian jobs being exported to Texas along with our oil, says Canada’s energy union, which filed leave to appeal the decision on Friday.

“The oil and gas industry has decided that the enormous economic development associated with upgrading and refining oil sands resources will take place in Texas, not Canada,” says Dave Coles, President of the Communications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada.

The Keystone XL pipeline construction project will export 900,000 barrels of oil per day to the US Gulf Coast -- most of which is unprocessed bitumen from the Alberta oil sands.

“This means the loss of tens of thousands of jobs in the Canadian oil upgrading and refining sector that either exist now, or that would have been created by projects that are likely to be cancelled as a result of the dramatic expansion of oil export pipeline capacity to upgraders and refineries in the U.S.”

Keystone XL was opposed by CEP, the Alberta Federation of Labour, the Sierra Club, and also by Enbridge, Imperial Oil, BP and Nexen.

The companies argued that Keystone XL will create enormous excess export capacity, raise service costs on other pipelines, and increase input costs to Canadian refineries by US$600 million in 2013.

“Not only will this project abandon the enormous opportunity of creating a diversified Canadian oil and gas industry,” says Coles, “but it will seriously undermine the viability of existing refineries.

“Astonishingly, the NEB has signed off on the industry’s plan as being the Canadian public interest.

“The Board has abandoned its mandate to the entirely ill-founded notion that a deregulated export market is in the Canadian public interest.”

The legal argument filed by CEP asserts that the NEB made several fundamental errors of law, and failed to properly exercise its mandate to protect the Canadian public interest.

The National Energy Board approved the Keystone XL pipeline project March 11, 2010, subject to the federal government giving it the final green light. CEP filed its appeal on April 9.

Keystone and its allies now have 20 days to respond to CEP’s application. A decision from the Federal Court of Appeal on whether an appeal will be allowed is expected in May.

The 150,000-member CEP is Canada’s largest union of energy workers, with about 35,000 members who work in the oil, gas and petro-chemical industries.

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Berendsen seeking leave to appeal to Supreme Court of Canada

In January, I reported on a decision by the Ontario Court of Appeal overturning a decision in favour of a farm family worth over $2.3 million.  At issue in the case was whether the Ontario government was liable for damages resulting from its deposit of asphalt on a dairy farm in the 1960's during highway construction.  The Court of Appeal ruled that the damages alleged were not reasonably foreseeable and were not recoverable.  My original post is at: Berendsen decision overturned by Ontario Court of Appeal.

The Berendsens are now seeking leave to appeal this decision to the Supreme Court of Canada.  Reply submissions were filed on March 8, so the next step will be the Supreme Court's decision on whether or not to allow the appeal to be heard.