Tractor

Tractor
Showing posts with label Federal Court of Appeal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Federal Court of Appeal. Show all posts

Thursday, June 30, 2016

Federal Court of Appeal overturns Northern Gateway approval

The Federal Court of Appeal has quashed the decision by the Federal Cabinet to approve the Northern Gateway pipeline project on the basis that Canada failed to consult adequately with First Nations on the pipeline route.  With changes to the National Energy Board Act made by the previous government, pipeline projects like the Northern Gateway project are subject only to a review by the National Energy Board.  The NEB then makes a recommendation to the Federal Cabinet, which has the ultimate say in whether a project is approved.

The appeal court ruled that Canada failed in its approach to consultation with First Nations on the project, noting that the government carried out consultations in a "brief, hurried and inadequate" way.

Read the decision at: Federal Court of Appeal.

Tuesday, December 22, 2015

COTTFN files for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in Enbridge Line 9B case

In October, I posted about the Federal Court of Appeal decision to deny an appeal by the Chippewas of the Thames First Nation ("COTTFN") from the decision of the National Energy Board ("NEB") approving the Enbridge Line 9B Reversal and Line 9 Capacity Expansion Project application.  COTTFN has now filed an application for leave to appeal the Federal Court of Appeal's decision to the Supreme Court of Canada.  Given that there was a dissenting opinion from one of the FCA judges and that the subject matter of the appeal concerns the role of administrative tribunals in relation to the Crown's duty to consult with and accommodate First Nations, there would seem to be a good chance that leave will be granted.

Thursday, October 29, 2015

Federal Court of Appeal split on Chippewas of the Thames appeal of NEB Line 9B Decision

In a split decision, the Federal Court of Appeal has dismissed the appeal of the Chippewas of the Thames First Nation of the National Energy Board's approval of Enbridge's Line 9B Reversal and Line 9 Expansion Project.  At issue in the appeal was the Federal Crown's duty to consult with First Nations - was the NEB required as part of its decision-making process to determine whether the Federal Crown (which was not a party to the NEB process) was under a duty to consult First Nations with respect to potential adverse impacts of the proposed project and, if so, whether it had adequately discharged that duty?

Ryer, J.A., writing for the majority of the Court in dismissing the appeal, found that that the NEB was not required as a precondition to its consideration of Enbridge's application to determine whether the Federal Crown was under a duty to consult (or whether it had discharged that duty) because the Federal Crown was not a participant in the Enbridge application.  Justice Ryer noted that, if the Crown had appeared before the NEB, these issues could have been argued.  However, the Federal Crown did not participate in the NEB approval process.

Justice Ryer then went on to consider whether the NEB itself has the power to undertake and discharge the duty to consult with First Nations on behalf of the Federal Crown.  He noted that it is within the power of Parliament to require the NEB to discharge the Crown's duty to consult, but it has not done so by legislation.  He questions how the NEB could both carry out the duty to consult and then adjudicate on whether or it had adequately discharged the duty.  Yet, in a letter sent by the Minister of Natural Resources concerning the Enbridge project, the Minister suggested that the Federal Government "relies on the NEB processes to address potential impacts to Aboriginal and treaty rights stemming from projects under its mandate."

Nevertheless, Justice Ryer concluded that there was no delegation of the duty to consult by the Federal Crown to the NEB.  Therefore, any shortcoming in the NEB's consultation with First Nations could not stand as a reason for setting aside its decision to consider Enbridge's application and, ultimately, to approve it.

Justice Rennie of the Federal Court of Appeal provided a dissenting opinion on the case.  His opinion was that the Supreme Court's 2010 decision in Rio Tinto Alcan Inc. v. Carrier Sekani Tribal Council meant that it was not necessary for the Federal Crown to be a party to the NEB proceeding in order for the NEB to be required to rule upon the Crown's duty to consult.  He viewed that decision of the Supreme Court as changing the law on the duty to consult.  As a result, Justice Rennie's opinion was the NEB must review the duty to consult in the context of a Section 58 application (like the Enbridge Line 9B application, which is not subject to final approval by the Federal Cabinet):

The Board must have, and exercise, the power to assess whether the duty to consult has been fulfilled, and to refuse to grant an approval if there is an unfulfilled duty to consult; otherwise the section 58 regime allows for the approval of projects which may adversely affect Aboriginal rights without the Crown ever consulting with the Aboriginal group in question. A project proponent can apply, go through the NEB's hearing process, and receive approval. The Crown can remain silent, on the sidelines. No consultation with the Crown need occur at any point. Indeed, the Crown lacks the statutory authority to prevent an application from being approved by the Board, even if it should want to.

Rennie, J.A. concluded that the NEB should have considered whether there was a duty to consult and, if so, whether it had been fulfilled.  And the NEB should only have granted approval to Enbridge if there was no unfulfilled duty to consult with First Nations.  Justice Rennie would have allowed the appeal.

Given the split in the Federal Court of Appeal on this appeal, this may very well be a case that will be heard by the Supreme Court of Canada.

The full text of the Federal Court of Appeal decision is available at: 2015 FCA 222.

Thursday, June 12, 2014

First Nation granted leave to appeal NEB's Enbridge Line 9B Reversal approval

The Chippewas of the Thames First Nation (COTTFN) has been granted leave to appeal the NEB's approval of the Enbridge Line 9B Reversal and Line 9 Capacity Expansion Project.  The COTTFN had to apply to the Federal Court of Appeal for leave as the first step in its challenge to the NEB decision on the basis that the Federal Crown failed to consult with it over the project.  COTTFN disputes that its participation in the NEB process or public consultation by Enbridge constitutes proper consultation by the Crown.  Read COTTFN's press release on the leave to appeal decision at: FEDERAL COURT OF APPEAL GRANTS CHIPPEWAS LEAVE.

The outcome of the appeal is obviously up in the air, but it is promising to see that COTTFN's arguments about Crown consultation will be heard by the Courts.  Similar arguments were raised by First Nations in the initial Line 9A reversal application hearing, but no appeals were taken from the NEB's approval of that project.  Without an appeal to the Courts, the NEB is left to make the only decisions about whether its own "consultation" process with First Nations fulfills the Crown's obligations.  A conflict of interest? 

Depending on the outcome of the appeal before the Federal Court of Appeal, this may be the kind of case that will go to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

CFIA loses bid for judicial review of tagging decision

The Federal Court of Appeal has rejected an application by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency for judicial review of a decision by the Canadian Agricultural Review Tribunal made last January.  In the decision, Dr. Don Buckingham of the Tribunal determined that CFIA had failed to prove on a balance of proabilities that lambs which arrived untagged after transport from Saskatchewan to Ontario had been untagged when they left the farm. 

The Federal Court of Appeal's decision was simple: "Based on the evidence before it, the Tribunal was entitled to make these factual findings. Given the deferential standard of review of reasonableness that applies in this case, there is no basis upon which we can set aside these factual findings. Therefore, the Tribunal’s conclusion that there was no violation must stand."

The decision itself in this case is not extraordinary.  However, it does raise practical questions about how farmers can respond to CFIA allegations related to untagged animals.  Note that the appeal took place in Toronto.  The farmer is located in Saskatchewan.  While it is likely that the hearing would have taken place in Saskatchewan had the farmer participated in the appeal (which he did not), one can question whether it would ever be worthwhile for a farmer to expend resources to respond to an appeal in a case involving a $500 penalty.  Having won at the Tribunal, at his own cost, could the farmer be expected to pay more money to fight a CFIA appeal of the decision?

Read the Federal Court of Appeal decision at: Canada (Attorney General) v. Rosemont Livestock.

Read the original decision of the Canadian Agricultural Review Tribunal at: Rosemont Livestock v. Canada (Canadian Food Inspection Agency), 2010 CART 004.

Friday, April 16, 2010

Communications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada appeals Keystone XL approval

CEP Press Release - 04/12/2010

TORONTO -- The National Energy Board has approved a pipeline construction project – Keystone XL – that will result in tens of thousands of current and potential Canadian jobs being exported to Texas along with our oil, says Canada’s energy union, which filed leave to appeal the decision on Friday.

“The oil and gas industry has decided that the enormous economic development associated with upgrading and refining oil sands resources will take place in Texas, not Canada,” says Dave Coles, President of the Communications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada.

The Keystone XL pipeline construction project will export 900,000 barrels of oil per day to the US Gulf Coast -- most of which is unprocessed bitumen from the Alberta oil sands.

“This means the loss of tens of thousands of jobs in the Canadian oil upgrading and refining sector that either exist now, or that would have been created by projects that are likely to be cancelled as a result of the dramatic expansion of oil export pipeline capacity to upgraders and refineries in the U.S.”

Keystone XL was opposed by CEP, the Alberta Federation of Labour, the Sierra Club, and also by Enbridge, Imperial Oil, BP and Nexen.

The companies argued that Keystone XL will create enormous excess export capacity, raise service costs on other pipelines, and increase input costs to Canadian refineries by US$600 million in 2013.

“Not only will this project abandon the enormous opportunity of creating a diversified Canadian oil and gas industry,” says Coles, “but it will seriously undermine the viability of existing refineries.

“Astonishingly, the NEB has signed off on the industry’s plan as being the Canadian public interest.

“The Board has abandoned its mandate to the entirely ill-founded notion that a deregulated export market is in the Canadian public interest.”

The legal argument filed by CEP asserts that the NEB made several fundamental errors of law, and failed to properly exercise its mandate to protect the Canadian public interest.

The National Energy Board approved the Keystone XL pipeline project March 11, 2010, subject to the federal government giving it the final green light. CEP filed its appeal on April 9.

Keystone and its allies now have 20 days to respond to CEP’s application. A decision from the Federal Court of Appeal on whether an appeal will be allowed is expected in May.

The 150,000-member CEP is Canada’s largest union of energy workers, with about 35,000 members who work in the oil, gas and petro-chemical industries.

Thursday, April 8, 2010

Canadian Natural Resources Limited appeal dismissed by Alberta Court of Appeal

The Alberta Court of Appeal has dismissed the appeal of Canadian Natural Resources Limited (CNRL) of a Court of Queen's Bench surface rights decision made in favour of landowners.  The most important ground of appeal revolved around criticisms which the Court of Queen’s Bench made of one of the CNRL’s witness’ expert evidence. There is case law which was not disputed on the appeal. It holds that if a pattern of dealings has been established, then compensation for compulsory imposition (or renewal) of a surface lease for an oil or gas well may be based on the negotiated amounts in those prior contracts between others. The Court of Queen’s Bench concluded that no such applicable pattern of dealings had been proved here (paras. 89, 118 and 155). That was a rejection of most of the evidence of this expert witness.

The Court of Queen's Bench had summarized the reasons for its rejection of the pattern of dealings evidence:
a) There was no definition, precise or general, of the area to which this pattern was said to apply.
b) There was no information with respect to how many sites, overall, are within the area.

c) There was no indication of how many sites were reviewed in order to ascertain the comparables, nor any indication of why other sites reviewed were not comparable.

d) There was no explanation of why this pattern was applicable to a certain area.

e) There was no information provided with respect to the number of parties, either operator or landowner, represented within the comparables.

f) There was no information with respect to the negotiation process.

g) With respect to the chart showing CNRL irrigation and dryland leases, almost half of the leases do not fit the compensation pattern.

h) There was no explanation of why leases that were presented as comparables but that did not fit the compensation pattern supported the pattern of dealings.

i) There was no explanation as to why initially only new agreements were considered appropriate comparables, but why later, rent reviews were also considered to be properly included.
The Court of Appeal found that the Court of Queen's Bench, as finder of fact, was entitled to reject the expert evidence of pattern of dealings.  There was no reversible error in the lower court decision.

Read the Alberta Court of Appeal decision at: 2010 ABCA 91 (CanLII).

Read the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench decision at: 88 Alta. L.R. (4th) 298

Saturday, February 6, 2010

Federal Court of Appeal overturns cattle tag decision in Denfield Livestock Sales case

A three-judge panel of the Federal Court of Appeal sitting in Montreal has overturned a decision of the Canada Agricultural Review Tribunal that found Denfield Livestock Sales Limited (DLS) not guilty of having moved cattle without a proper CFIA tag. The Tribunal had ruled that DLS, as auctioneer, did not take ownership and control over the cattle and, therefore, did not cause the movement of the cattle from its facilities to the purchaser's farm. The Attorney-General of Canada decided to seek the judicial review of this decision mainly on the basis that the Tribunal was wrong when it determined that DFS did not have sufficient power and control over the animals to be required by the regulations to ensure that they were properly tagged. The Court of Appeal agreed.

In arriving at its decision, the Court of Appeal analyzed the contractual relationship between vendor, auctioneer and purchaser. Although the auctioneer takes no part in the contract of sale directly between vendor and purchaser, the auctioneer is entrusted by the vendor with possession of the goods being sold, and the auctioneer cannot give up the goods to the purchaser until the purchaser has paid the purchase price. In this way, the Court decided, the Tribunal decision was incorrect in finding that the auctioneer did not have power and control over the animals.

The Court of Appeal has now sent the case back to the Tribunal to be reconsidered on the basis that DFS did have care and control of the animals sufficient to create a duty to tag under the regulations.

The decision of the Federal Court of Appeal is available (but only in French) at:
http://www.canlii.org/fr/ca/caf/doc/2010/2010caf36/2010caf36.html

The original decision of the Canada Agricultural Appeal Tribunal is available at:
http://cart-crac.gc.ca/index_e.php?s1=decisions&page=a60328