Tractor

Tractor
Showing posts with label discharge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label discharge. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Ontario MOE: Company fined $50,000 for manure discharge

From the MOE Court Bulletin:

Warwick Company Fined $50,000 for Discharging Manure into Woods Creek


Sarnia – A Warwick company was fined $50,000 for discharging a mixture of cow manure and leachate into Woods Creek that could have impaired the creek’s water quality, contrary to the Ontario Water Resources Act.

“Polluters should be aware that the ministry’s Investigations and Enforcement Branch will vigorously pursue charges when our environmental laws are broken”, Environment Minister Jim Bradley.

Eusi Farms Ltd. operates a beef feed lot located on Rawlings Road in the Municipality of Lambton Shores where approximately 3,000 cattle are housed. Manure is stored on site until applied as a nutrient to 14 other Eusi farms.

On November 19, 2011, a resident of Lambton Shores reported to the ministry that Woods Creek was black and smelled like manure. The caller also reported seeing dead fish, crayfish and several frogs in the creek. The Municipality of Lambton Shores staff attended the site and reported a strong odour, discoloured water and dead fish.

An inspection conducted by ministry staff revealed the source of the contamination in the creek was a leaking manure pit located at the Eusi Farms about seven kilometres upstream of Lake Huron.

Ministry staff remained at the site until the leak was fixed and clean-up work completed. .

Eusi Farms Ltd. was fined $50,000 plus a victim fine surcharge of $12,500 and was given 60 days to pay the fine.

Thursday, July 18, 2013

Company fined for manure discharge into municipal drain

From the Ministry of the Environment:

Shedden Company Fined $25,000 for Manure Discharge


St. Thomas - A Shedden company was fined $25,000 for discharging pig manure into the Kerstan Municipal Drain causing impairment to the quality of water.

"Polluters should be aware that the ministry's Investigations and Enforcement Branch will vigorously pursue charges when our environmental laws are broken," Environment Minister Jim Bradley.

G.H. Pennings Farms Inc. owns and operates a pig farm located in Southwold Township. The Ministry of Natural Resources received a call from a local resident regarding manure impacting a creek. The tip was relayed to the Ministry of the Environment and ministry inspectors attended the site. During the inspection, staff traced the source of the manure back to a holding lagoon located on the farm. The lab results of the water samples taken at the site showed impairment to water quality.

The company was fined $25,000 plus a victim fine surcharge of $6,250 and was given six months to pay the fine.

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Court of Appeal upholds conviction under EPA for rock debris

The Ontario Court of Appeal, in a split decision 2-1, has upheld the conviction of a highway construction subcontractor under the Environmental Protection Act (EPA) related to rock debris that travelled 90 metres beyond the controlled blasting area.  The "fly-rock" landed on a house and vehicle on neighbouring private property causing damage.  The blasting company did not report the debris and was subsequently charged with failing to report the discharge of a contaminant into the environment contrary to Section 15(1) of the EPA. 

The duty to report depended on whether there had been a discharge within the meaning of Section 14(1) of the EPA.  Section 14(1) prohibits a discharge of a contaminant into the natural environment if the discharge causes or may cause an adverse effect.  "Adverse effect" is a defined term in the Act, and the majority of the Court of Appeal panel found that for the harms listed in subparagraphs (b) to (h), there is no requirement that there necessarily be harm to the environment (i.e. there can be an adverse effect for the purposes of Section 14(1) without harm to the environment).  On this basis, although the "fly-rock" caused no apparent harm to the environment, the conviction was upheld.

Justice Robert Blair wrote a dissenting opinion.  His view was that there could be no "adverse effect" without either non-trivial harm or impairment of the natural environment.  As it was conceded that the "fly-rock" had no more than a trivial or minor impact on the natural environment, Justice Blair would have allowed the appeal.


Saturday, October 29, 2011

Ministry of the Environment: $48,000 fine levied for manure discharge

Bernardus Johannes Joseph Debeer Fined $48,000 For Manure Discharge


THUNDER BAY– On August 8, 2011, Bernardus Johannes Joseph DeBeer pleaded guilty to one violation under the Ontario Water Resources Act for a discharge of corn silage and manure into the Curry Municipal Drain and Reynolds Creek.

The Court heard that Mr. DeBeer is the president of a dairy and veal farm in the Municipality of South-West Oxford, Ontario.  In 2009, the ministry received a report of dead fish in Reynolds Creek.  The ministry conducted sampling on the farm and observed that run-off from the corn silage was entering catch basins. Mr. DeBeer confirmed that he had been receiving corn silage for more than a week and also confirmed that the catch basins were connected to the Curry municipal drain which flowed into Reynolds Creek.

Mr. DeBeer was charged following an investigation by the ministry’s Investigations and Enforcement Branch.  He was fined $48,000 plus a victim fine surcharge and was given six months to pay the fine.

Friday, February 19, 2010

Keep it down! MOE fines for discharge of contaminants including sound

On November 19 last year, GB Scrap Metal Ltd. and George Bois pled guilty to violations of Ontario's Environmental Protection Act for the discharge of contaminants - sound, vibrations and scrap metal. The charges related to an explosion at the scrap yard caused when an employee sheared a compressed gas cylinder that apparently hadn't been entirely emptied.

Read the MOE's press release at: http://www.ene.gov.on.ca/en/news/2010/010502.php

Under the Environmental Protection Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E-19 ("EPA"), a contaminant means "any solid, liquid, gas, odour, heat, sound, vibration, radiation or combination of any of them resulting directly or indirectly from human activities that causes or may cause an adverse effect". Note, however, that certain noise and odour produced from farming activities may be exempt from restrictions under the EPA pursuant to normal farm practices protection legislation.